We all know that I have had milk supply issues. Up until recently, I hadn’t really given a lot of thought to how rare true supply issues are and what the underlying cause may have been. At first I didn’t know if it was a true supply issue or something I had done wrong (we really do hang on to that mommy guilt, don’t we?). But I have learned enough about breastfeeding since then to know that it wasn’t anything I did wrong.

In my (in no way professional) opinion, a lot of women do worry about their supply. Some then start to supplement unnecessarily, which in turn hurts their supply because the best way to increase supply is to increase demand (i.e. nurse more). That means the less you nurse (since you’re supplementing instead), the less milk you make. It is a downward spiral for a lot of women. We did everything we could to avoid that. When we were finally forced to supplement, hubby gave supplement bottles after I nursed and I pumped while he did that. I wrote about having to supplement here. I also took Fenugreek for several months.

I knew that I had supply issues. And I knew that they weren’t my fault. But still, every time I heard about Insufficient Glandular Tissue, I immediately dismissed it. My boobs are pretty huge, so I must have sufficient tissue. Until last week. I heard about it again and decided to look into it a little bit. I couldn’t find any information at all in my usual go-to places (kellymom & Ask Dr. Sears). So I dug deeper.

I came across this page with symptoms of Insufficient Glandular Tissue. My comments are italicized.

Strong Indicators That You May Have Insufficient Glandular Tissue:

1. You did not experience any changes in your breasts during puberty/pregnancy. – This doesn’t apply, my boobs got much larger during puberty and pregnancy.

2. You did not experience postpartum breast engorgement. – None. I have never been engorged  no matter how long I have gone without feeding.

3. Your baby is not gaining weight.  It is abnormal for a newborn baby to lose more than 10% of his birth weight.  Also, newborns should be back up to their birth weight by the time they are 3 weeks old.  While this is the NUMBER ONE symptom to indicate a lack of milk supply, this symptom alone is not enough to indicate IGT.  It would be necessary to rule out other reasons for the lack of growth such as poor latching, underlying conditions of the baby, poor nutrition of the mother, etc. A baby scale can be helpful for you to determine your baby’s exact milk intake during a feeding. Baby scales may be available for use at your local hospital or from a local lactation consultant. – Yes! The Gnome lost more than 10% of his birth weight and did not gain any back until we started to supplement with formula.

4. You do not hear any swallowing sounds when you breastfeed. -  Looking back now, I know he wasn’t making any swallowing sounds. I actually didn’t hear him swallow until he was over a month old. I just didn’t realize it at the time because I didn’t know what to look for. 

I had additional symptoms as well:

  • I had no evidence of my milk “coming in.” I never felt engorged, never had an increase in flow, and I never felt let down.
  • My baby was insatiable. He nursed until he passed out, slept for 20 – 30 minutes, and then woke up ravenous again. It was a never-ending cycle that exhausted all three of us until we finally started supplementing with an ounce of formula after each feeding.
  • Very few wet diapers. Dark urine and urea crystals in diapers (looks like “brick dust”).

From mobimotherhood.org, which stands for Mothers Overcoming Breastfeeding Issues (again, my comments are italicized):

Breast shape is listed as one of the risk indicators for low milk supply due to insufficient glandular tissue (IGT). While there is no one breast shape or kind of tissue that always indicates a reduced ability to produce milk, certain physical characteristics may indicate a problem with milk supply. Having irregularly shaped breasts, one breast that is dramatically smaller than the other (yes!), breasts that are very widely spaced on the chest wall (yes!), breasts that lack fullness (yes!), and other characteristics may be diagnostic.

Diagnosis of IGT is often done by an IBCLC examining the breasts. Women with this diagnosis frequently do go on to develop a milk supply, though not always a full supply.

Severe IGT can lead to the production of very little or no milk. The most reliable sign of severe IGT is the complete lack of breast changes during pregnancy and after birth.

In researching Insufficient Glandular Tissue, I’m learning more about it. Like, it can take up to a month to establish your milk supply if you have it (check!). That my boobs look the part. That taking Goat’s Rue would have been more effective than taking Fenugreek. Also that I will most likely have more milk with subsequent babies.

I should have been more persistent when I got brushed off by the lactation office at the hospital where I delivered. I shouldn’t have been shy when it came to asking for help. I should have demanded an appointment to see them. I will be looking for an IBCLC. I need to know what my problem was, even if it isn’t Insufficient Glandular Tissue. It is something & I would like to be better prepared for the next baby.

Have you heard of Insufficient Glandular Tissue? While rare, women do experience true supply issues. Have you experienced any? Do you have any links to additional information on IGT? If you enjoy reading about The Gnome & his family, like us on Facebook and follow us on twitter! While you’re at it… check out our Networked Blogs box in the right sidebar and consider joining through Google Friend Connect, will ya?

 

 

  • Dee

    I had never heard of IGT until you mentioned it.  During pregnancy I learned that breast size doesn’t determine milk production (I’m sure a lot of people would assume it does – I guess it just goes to reason really, in anything else, a larger container will hold more), but that it’s surprisingly enough it’s women with larger breasts that end up having supply issues more frequently.  Did anything you read about IGT say anything about size, other than not changing during pregnancy and after birth?

    I definitely got engorged, but I didn’t ever find it painful like some women do – uncomfortable, but not painful.  And I certainly remember my milk coming in – it was actually pretty humorous.  I was getting ready to take a shower, but had to pee before I got in.  So I’m sitting there, doing the postpartum wash routine after you’ve used the bathroom, and I’m hearing this dripping noise, but not dripping into water.  And it took me a minute to realize I was leaking all over the floor!  I know, TMI, but I know you don’t mind. ;)  It was pretty funny though, because I just couldn’t figure out what it was!

    So glad that the issues we had weren’t supply related, because really, there’s only so much you can do.  The problems I had just had to be toughed out.  But, I knew going into it that it would probably be difficult in the beginning, and I definitely think it helps to have that understanding.

    • http://thegnomesmom.com Lori W

      I knew right away that breast size doesn’t make a difference because despite having fairly large breasts, I have barely any milk LOL.

      IGT is common in women with hypoplastic breasts. All of the ones that I saw were small – but mine look like bigger versions of those. They look a little off but because they’re larger it is much less obvious than the ones I saw pictures of. They have the defining characteristics but could still pass as mostly normal if you weren’t looking specifically for hypoplasia.

      I never leaked so I can’t commiserate with the women who ended up with soaked shirts in the grocery store! I can just picture you in your postpartum new baby zombie state trying to figure out wth that noise is!

      I knew that it would be tough in the beginning but the thought that I wouldn’t make enough milk and would have to supplement with formula never crossed my mind. I am really fortunate though, a lot of nursing pairs never recover from supplementation and some women with IGT don’t ever develop an adequate milk supply. We did, and I did. But, I still worry about how little milk he got in the beginning and if it will affect his development (once we added solids he’s gone from the 0 – 5th percentile to the  25th percentile so he was obviously lacking no matter how anyone tries to justify it).

      I feel much better prepared for baby #2. I know that I will likely make more milk but I also won’t be so opposed to supplementation (and now that I know about donor milk – that is also an option). Before I was afraid that supplementation would ruin nursing for us. Now I know that he NEEDED it and my perseverance is what shaped our nursing relationship – not the fact that we had to supplement. I have a whole blog post I need to write now about how complete dedication to ONLY nursing could have actually hurt my baby…. ok, I’m done now, mostly.

      Once Gnomie goes down for his nap I have a new in-law rant to message you LOL.

      • Dee

        Thankfully I never had any embarrassing leaking incidents, but it was amazing how much would leak out of the side not being nursed on!  In the beginning when I was having a lot of pain I wore breast shells/shields to keep my clothing from rubbing, and it was incredible how much milk collected in them when I was nursing.  Since then I’ve seen those Milk Savers that you wear on the breast not being nursed from – such a good idea!

        I know it’s frustrating that it took you so long to figure out what was going on, but even though you didn’t know you still made the situation work, and under those circumstances that was incredible! :)

  • Mommy C

    I’m dropping by from the Breastfeeding Blog Hop to say hello! :)
    This is a really informative article. I had never heard of this before – and I read A LOT. Thanks so much for the info!
    Crystal
    http://www.SoooBig.WordPress.com

  • http://DianaIBCLC.com Diana

    This is a topic that is very important to me — please see the work I’ve done so far:
    http://www.llli.org/llleaderweb/lv/lviss2-3-2009p4.html (an article for La Leche League’s Leader publication, Leaven)

    There is also a podcast (45 minutes) on this topic on the Motherlove Herbal company’s blog (can’t get a link to that because it’s not opening here on my work computer).

    Feel free to share the information with your healthcare providers — I’m doing all I can to get the word out for moms like you.  You need support and it seems no one even recognizes this condition. 

    With much love,
    Diana

    • http://thegnomesmom.com Lori W

      Thank you so much. I’ve listened to the podcast but I hadn’t seen the article. Reading it convinced me further that this was my problem. Although I’m frustrated it took me almost 10 months to figure it out, I’m thankful that I know now. I’m also thankful that I didn’t give up when we had to supplement.

      I will keep spreading the word. Ultimately I would like to meet with an IBCLC and have this verified but I have so many of the signs. With as much as I looked for help in the beginning – I can’t believe I kept dismissing this possibility. Thanks again Diana.

  • http://twitter.com/anjanetteopal Anjanette Barr

    I think I have this to a degree. My breasts look like my moms, so I never wondered about them. They are small, but I know that plenty of women with small breasts lactate fine. I had trouble with my first baby, but we nursed until 3 years! It did mean nursing almost around the clock until he started solids, though. I’m happy to tell you that when my second was born, it was like I had new breasts (so THATS what a let down feels like!!!) and we are still nursing well at 17 months. I think that nursing all the way through her pregnancy helped a ton as there was no adjustment period. My milk came in within 24 hours!

    • http://thegnomesmom.com Lori W

      That is amazing! I am convinced I will have more milk next time. But even if I don’t, I know how to successfully nurse with what I’ve got.

  • http://www.tea4tamara.com Tamara

    Just stopping by as I tour the blog hop. :) I love your dedication to nursing. So so many women would have given up, but instead you kept at it and your helping educate other women too. Awesome!

  • http://twitter.com/Playersnamed Erin Clotfelter

    I had never heard of this either- and I pretty much fall into every category (except I did get boobs in puberty, but no changes with pregnancy).  It took Judah 2 weeks and 6 days to *almost* get back to his birth weight (he lost more than 10%), but he pretty much stayed tiny until we started supplementing formula on top of his already constant nursing (and my pathetic pumping).  I wish I had taken pictures of him before and after that first bottle, because OMG my baby got cheeks and thighs like overnight.  Until we started solids at 6 months he was attached to me for 45-90 minutes at a time all day long with maybe a 60 minute break if I was lucky.  He was the unhappiest baby on the block, always whiny, never sleeping.  That extra bottle to top him off was our saving grace.

    I did whatever I could to avoid formula- Reglan (that’ll make you want to jump out of your skin), pumping from day 1, Fenugreek, nursing vacations etc, we supplemented pumped milk with a dropper for weeks.  He’s just a big kid (in the 97th percentile in all categories now) and he needed way more than I had to give.  I remember sitting in the LC’s office and her telling me everything was great (and it was, there was just nothing to show for the good work he was doing) except she didn’t hear swallowing.  I told her I always heard swallowing…but until I actually heard swallowing, I had NO idea what I was listening for.  Now that we are weaning I listen like a hawk, it’s slowing down for sure.  I made my long term goal though- 1 year, limped over the line.  It wasn’t EBF, but it was what we could do.

    Great post Lori- so much better than the ones that gloss over the issue with the standard “lots of women think they have low supply, but it’s so rare…..”.  They just leave you feeling like how on earth could you possibly be lucky enough to be in the rare group and then you are back to square one, thinking it’s all in your head, feeling guilty because you can’t make it work.  Not helpful at all.  Good tip about the Goat’s Rue- I have never heard of it…

    • http://thegnomesmom.com Lori W

      Your story sounds so familiar. How insane is it that more women don’t know about this? You’re absolutely right, I couldn’t believe that I was actually in the “rare” small percentage of women that didn’t make enough. Well, I was. I tried everything short of Reglan and Domperidone (which scared me).

      I don’t know if you saw the link Diana posted: http://www.llli.org/llleaderweb/lv/lviss2-3-2009p4.html

      There is also a podcast on Motherlove Herbal’s website: http://motherloveblog.com/tag/breast-hypoplasia/

      That podcast was what made me realize, “holy shit! This is me.”

      Motherlove makes a More Milk Special Blend with Goat’s Rue that I will be using the moment I give birth with #2. I am hoping to have an entirely different experience next time around.

      • http://www.facebook.com/rachel.m.mitchell Rachel Mitchell

        You can actually take Goat’s Rue towards the end of your pregnancy to encourage breast tissue growth. You mentioned MOBI before, they have a document about how to prepare for a better chance at breastfeeding in their yahoo group

  • Pingback: Next Time « The Gnome's Mom

  • Pingback: Breastfeeding Blog Hop: Pressure Gauges | Sisters 'n Cloth

  • Nursemommypaige

    someone suggested I research this, and it sounds just like me! I tried to BF with my son,  but only made colostrum. I was so disappointed in myself! I am bound and determined to BF with this baby I am carrying, now that I have something to ask the doctor about, I feel more confident! 

    • http://thegnomesmom.com Lori W

      Just know that you will probably produce more with your second too :) I am glad this gave you some insight!

  • Babyeato12

    This is the problem that my lactation consultant said I have. Even then, I still continue to pump eight times a day, take fenugreek, shatavari and goat’s rue. My baby is almost five months old and we still have to supplement with formula everyday. It’s sad because we are in the rare percentage and most other women don’t understand, even if they were breastfeeding women. Most of them cannot believe how anyone can not have a full supply and think its just due to mismanagement of breastfeeding. They try to make me guilty although I know I’ve tried harder than any of them. That said, I’m still glad that my baby is growing healthily, be it with breast milk or formula and I will still keep pumping to provide whatever I’ve got.

    • http://thegnomesmom.com Lori W

      It takes a strong and determined mama to make it 5 months through IGT. Good for you!

  • Andrea

    The good news about IGT is that with 2nd and subsequent pregnancies, IGT women tend to grow glandular tissue and can have success with breastfeeding. I didn’t have a drop of milk with #1, but #2 breastfed with some formula supplementation (for the first 7 months) for 34 months! And true supply issues are not that rare. One in 10 women suffer from PCOS, and a LOT of women with PCOS have TRUE supply issues.